Interesting. I would have rated realism as far more important. This would follow with the interface and "gameplay" in that order. Yes, it should be fun but, for me much of the fun is that it is challenging and realistic. I want to be able to apply what I know of history to the game and see it work.
The AI opponet would have also rated very high.
The fluff stuff like sound, graphics, packaging are all definitely secondary to the above.

__________________
Truth is stranger than bullshit!