View Single Post
  #8 (permalink)  
Old October 23rd, 2007, 12:25 AM
Carl W Schwamberger Carl W Schwamberger is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 578
Salute!: 0
Saluted 2 Times in 1 Post
Carl W Schwamberger has a spectacular aura aboutCarl W Schwamberger has a spectacular aura about
Default Re: What if Germans attacked through Maginot?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Wessex Wyvern View Post
51st Highland Division were manning the Maginot Line in May 1940.
They had some action there.

I have read elsewhere that the Highlanders thought very little of the offensive spirit of the French troops manning the Line. I suppose if you're sat in a supposedly impregnable fortifcation, you're not going to feel very offensive minded.
See
Looking over the field formations posted to the fortified zoe I'd agree. The infantry divsions there seem to be average R & A types with a few of the third wave B divsions. Those were all configured for defensive fighting, with any attacking to be in the form of methodical carefully planned counter strikes with heavy artilery support.

The other type of unit posted to the fortress zone were the fortification regiments. These were a elite organization, but their sole offensive role was to provide fire support. Defending against the German attacks they did well and were amoung the last French soldiers to surrender.

The force for large scale counter strikes were the armored, and motorized infantry, divsions posted further west. These constituted the formations trained for attacking and which were suitable for a large scale counter strike.

Historically this powerfull mechanized force of over a dozen divisions was misdeployed and scattered due to the French leaders misreading the German attack. Its corps and individual divsions were defeated piecemeal. Had the Germans been foolish enough to attack the fortified zone directly the French leaders probablly would have concentrated their mechanized corps correctly.
Reply With Quote