View Single Post
  #3 (permalink)  
Old February 19th, 2008, 11:00 PM
von Rundstedt von Rundstedt is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Nov 2007
Posts: 515
von Rundstedt has a spectacular aura aboutvon Rundstedt has a spectacular aura about
Default Re: Prince of Wales and Repulse are sent to the DEI

Quote:
Originally Posted by T. A. Gardner View Post
This is a very interesting and potentially likely what if from the opening days of the Pacific War. What if instead of the Prince of Wales and Repulse being sent to attempt to intercept the Japanese landings in Malaysia they, along with their four escort destroyers are diverted to Java / the DEI to link up with the various naval forces already there.
The reasoning might be that without air cover the Malaysia operation was too risky and covering Australia and the DEI where there is a better chance of success due to other Allied naval forces in the area.
This would have given the ABDA fleet a battleship, a battlecruiser, 2 heavy cruisers, 5 or 6 light cruisers, and as many as 20 + destroyers. Against this the largest Japanese combatant in the area is a heavy cruiser. The Japanese also lack easy access to air power unlike they have in Malaysia and would have made it possible for the British capital ships to operate at sea without undue concern for being successfully attacked by aircraft.
Given the occasionally successful operations of the ABDA fleet it is entirely possible that this addition might have stopped one or more Japanese amphibious assaults through the annihiliation of the ships involved. In at least a couple of cases, ABDA ships...primarily destroyers... put severe hurt on Japanese landings. A thouough pasting of one or two by two battleships could have wiped out an entire transport group ending the landing and any possibility of immediate success.
Wow very impressive.

This may be crazy but it may have worked, indeed had this senario had worked then the Japanese drive into SE Asia and South Pacific may have hit a halt, giving time for places like Malaya/Singapore and other areas to re-enforce themselves, it may have gone asforas to delay the Japanese, buying time for the allies, which if indeed the Japanese had failed then time is critical, due in no small part the expenditure of valuable fuel oil and the loss of entire IJN taskforce. Also imagine that the Dutch East Indies had not fallen and the the ABDA were able to use the DEI as forward bases of operations, this could have lead to an earlier defeat of Japan.
Reply With Quote