Thread: French Tanks
View Single Post
  #46 (permalink)  
Old May 23rd, 2008, 09:51 AM
Asterix Asterix is offline
Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Indiana
Posts: 80
Salute!: 0
Saluted 0 Times in 0 Posts
Asterix will become famous soon enough
Default Re: French Tanks

Quote:
Originally Posted by Za Rodinu View Post
The fact remains that after the experience of the Poland campaign the French tank doctrine did not buge, so whatever local victories there were, were totally irrelevant within a wider strategic environment, "victories without a tomorrow" per the title of the book by Gen. René Prioux.
The fact also remains that for some reason, despite the overall outcome, the engagement is considered a German victory. I disagree. Hence my point that however short it was, the French withdrew not by force of arms of the Germans, but on their own accords after the German left the battlefield. This does not make it "totally irrelevant", unless you're willing to state also that British actions at Arras were also "totally irrelevant". That engagement also did not produce a wider strategic environment which changed the outcome, so I really wonder what your point is here.

...and yes, I am aware of Gen. Prioux's book, though I do not own a copy myself.



Quote:
Originally Posted by Za Rodinu View Post
Name me a single dedicated LW anti-tank aircraft. It's still a bit early for the Ju 87G or the Hs 129, but I'll grant you that the logistical trains are very sensitive to air action.

In the meantime I found this HyperWar: The War in France and Flanders, 1939-1940 (UK Military Series)
Are you actually suggesting that the LW was not dive-bombing French/Allied columns? There exists coutless testimonies of Allied troop movements being harrased and mauled by attacks from the air. As for the link, it is an interesting read, though very heavily slanted towards the British view, thus I'd say it only tells part of the story. Naturally, there are descrepencies and ommissions too, but that remains for another discussion....
Reply With Quote