This is'nt really a what-if, just would like one's opinion of "other" Commanders had they been in charge of 6th Army in Stalingrad.

Guderian/Hoth/ Rommel / Kesselring /etc. Would Hitler had sacrificed a Guderian? Would a Rommel had dis-obeyed and pulled 6th Army out before it was too late?

Interesting question. I would say that Hitler would not sacrifice his experienced and successful generals such as Rommel, Manstein, Rundstedt and so on. He did pull Rommel out of Afrika. As for Guderian, I would say the Hitler may have let him go.

As for responses, Rommel probably would have pulled out as would Heinrici, Guderian or Manteuffel. Shroeder, Model, Rundstedt would have stayed. Hard to say though. The collapse of the Hungarian, Italian and Rumanian fronts caused the counteroffesive to be so quick that there may not have been a chance to perform an orderly withdrawal and may have resulted in a melee towards Rostov

__________________

American by birth, TEXAN by the grace of GOD!

Hard to say a thing about Rommel. he had made the decision to pull back at Alamein and once he heard the Hitler order that his DAK men could only die in their trenches with honor he cancelled the retreat. So not sure if Rommel would order a retreat from Stalingrad.

However Paulus never would have dared to go against Hitler´s wishes.And like we have read neither Manstein dared to order anything directly...

I guess it would depend on how things would go after that. Häusser left Kharkov against orders but as the later phases went excellently Hitler could not put him in the court, really.

I´d think Guderian, Hoth and Kesselring out of these would have come out and probably sacrificed their career as well. Some one might have lost his head as well but not Guderian, I think.

One of the problems here is like PzJgr says that the 6th Army held a big number of Soviet troops stuck for some 2 1/2 months.

__________________

I am going to agree with Kai on this one.... this really is an interesting question...

Rommel probably had a better chance of retreating then say Hoth or Paulus.
But then Again Hitler himself was in a stage of denial as to what was really going on at Stalingrad he just couldnt imagine that the city had not fallen yet.

__________________
The war against Russia will be such that it cannot be conducted in a knightly fashion. This struggle is one of ideologies and racial differences and will have to be conducted with unprecedented, unmerciful and unrelenting harshness. -Adolf Hitler

Until the Germans were surrounded there was not an officer in the Wehrmacht that would have pulled out. Remember that there was only a tiny strech of land between the Wehrmacht and the Volga. Against any other nation of the world the Germans would have been winning. But Ivan gave his life to let the Red Army organise the counterstroke.

Of the mentioned German commanders I guess Guderian would have argued the most to attempt a breakout of the Kessel. This because he had moral courage and plenty of prestige. Guderian got the sack many times for his pursuit of his views. The least likly to do anything useful would be Rommel. He did not have the capabilities to command an Army, (as shown from 1942 untill his death) and would rather die than to be a falling star. Hoth I don't know, because I know to little of him. Manstein might have organised the Army differently and got all the way to the Volga. But I think that the Russians would have broken his flanks anyways.

I have always perceived the forces to be too small for the job. As the logistics got streched the advantage of the germans faded. The real strength of the Wehrmacht was fighting in the open anyways.

__________________
'We march. The enemy is retreating in transport. We follow on foot.' Lt.Neil McCallum 5/7 Gordons 19th November 1942

Von Reichenau would have been an interesting one in Stalingrad. He was originally the commander of the 6th Army but died and Paulus replaced him. Nazi to the bone but also a very feared man.

__________________

Guderian is the only real possibility I see here pulling out prior to any direct order from der Fuehrer. However, as was the thesis of a paper I wrote in university, had there been another commander of 6th Army, such as those mentioned above, I think the situation at Stalingrad very well might have been much different. Paulus was inexperienced and unimaginative in my opinion and incorrect for the job from day one.

__________________
Cheers,
Daniel

Now all we need to know is whether and where your paper is available online (please?)

__________________
Everly Brothers - What I Have To Do Is Dream
"Never wrestle with pigs, you both end up getting dirty and the pig likes it."

Not at the moment, but I might see about making it so.

__________________
Cheers,
Daniel

It just seemed like it didn't matter to Hitler, he would have sacrificed anyone, probably even his family if it came to it. Soviets did a great job stopping the German 6th Army in Stalingrad overall.

Well, 6th Army almost defeated Chuikov's 64th, but then the Soviets were really letting them draw further and further along the lobster trap, feeding 64th drip by drip, while concentrating all the rest in the flanks.

And welcome aboard SF!

__________________
Everly Brothers - What I Have To Do Is Dream
"Never wrestle with pigs, you both end up getting dirty and the pig likes it."

This is very true. I wonder if Chuikov was aware of his army being sacrificed to entice the Germans? I wonder how he felt if he was aware. Beevor's book does present some instances where Chuikov was emotional about what happened to his men but did not say whether or not he knew about the massive reserves being built up around him.

__________________

American by birth, TEXAN by the grace of GOD!

I also think it's a question about what the commander in question would have done before and during the soviet attack:

- Keep the armoured units intact and not commit them to the city filled with rubble.
- Keep horses with the 6th Army, and thus enabling 6th Army to move without losing all the haevy equipment immediately.
- Immediately commit the reserves (which later got ordered to each and every direction) Hitler had placed in the rear areas to counter any soviet attack against the axis forces securing the flank.


_

__________________
Third Reich & WWII in the News - Medals, Battles & Aftermath