You don't know, so you can't say there's no harm to releasing them. Is that clear? And you don't know there's any harm in releasing them,...
And you know this how? This will go nowhere.....obviously that's a judgement call. You are espousing the CT that those files will reveal...
OK, let me rephrase that, there's no national security reason why those decrypts shouldn't be made public after 70 years. What conspiracy theory...
However, given the overall picture we really don't need that file. If the USN or FDR had known the attack was coming there is absolutely no good...
Well then I suggest we stick to the real issue here, the classified decrypts. Your opinion is there's nothing of value in them. You may be right...
Is that the best you can do?
I made it clear in 2 previous posts that I wasn't making an accussation that we had broken JN-25 prewar and knew the plan of attack and let it...
Thanks, now I'm going to have to go back and reread all my eastern front books and have some proper perpective.
Why do you insist on referring to my very specific and rational questions about PH as conspiracy theory run amok? The FACT is we were reading at...
The First Team, Lundstrom (both books) Shattered Sword, Parshall The Battle of Kursk, Glantz Basically, anything with new info
I'm sorry, I didn't realize I made a judgement. Your reply is a bit contradictory. First you say it would be nice to see the material declassified...
The real issue in my mind is how much of the JN25B naval code were we reading and what was decrypted prior to the attack. We will never know the...
