You don't know, so you can't say there's no harm to releasing them. Is that clear? And you don't know there's any harm in releasing them, that's why I said it's pointless. You are promoting a conspiracy theory. That's why I keep saying it. I'm not interested in your motivations, even if I were inclined to believe what you say about them. No, I'm not promoting your stereotypical view of this CT. You keep telling us you feel I am, it doesn't make it true. Obviously I don't care what you "believe", or your feelings either. I said it would be nice to see those decrypts. It would shut up the fringers about them. But then they'd just go on to something else. Other than that, I'm not particularly interested in them. If we had been reading JN-25b before Pearl Harbor we wouldn't have been struggling so hard to find out what "AF" was six months laters Your attitude toward seeing these decrypts is at odds with this supposed lifelong devotion to WWII knowledge. I think you should rethink the Midway comment considering the inaccuracy of story of the battle up to 5 years ago. Do you still think 'Kido Butai' was loaded with armed and fueled aircraft ready to attack TF16 and 17 when the SBD's came hurtling down? Maybe Fuchida, Kurita, and their staff made up a story when they were sailing back to Japan with their tails between their legs. Or is that a conspiracy theory? I'll quote you again, "we should withhold judgement until we have all the facts" Were you being rhetorical, or do you really believe that?