Hey all! I was wondering, were there many sub on sub torpedo kills in the Atlantic (or the Pacific for that matter, but I can't post in two fora at once)? Were they on the surface? I don't think they had real homing torpedoes in WWII -- and certainly not anything similar to the modern wire guided semi-active sonar homing torps of today. I know I am asking a BIG ASS question, but I do that, and I love the conversations they sometimes generate because so many of you are hardcore experts on this stuff, while I am MOST DEFINITELY NOT! LOL I ask one thing though -- Remember to argue an argument and NOT THE PERSON! Keep personal feelings out of the discussion please? I have had a couple of really promising threads get locked because some folks (who shall remain nameless) got their collective panties in wads and went off on others. Thank you. Really. Thank you.