Ok. So we're looking for Best Military Tactician - I assume that means maneuvering, using what materials and manpower was available, attacking and counter attacking, etc. To what degree would you consider something a success? You could look at Operation Market Garden as a failure (which it was) but on a more minute level the rescue of the Red Devils at Arnhem was quite a coupe and a success. You need to lay clear groundwork for these qualifiers. Descriptive descriptions of the criteria.