I have got the 12th edition of this book, printed in the year 2005, and there are even more communist bullshits, than were in the first edition....
I don't know, if we read the same book (Memories and thoughts). I am now somewhere at about page 200 (August 1939, battle of Khalkhin-Gol), but I...
I am reading Zhukov's Memories and Thoughts right now, so I'll see whatever is true or not as true. Now seems to me, Zhukov glorifies a bit too,...
I'll try to find that book, but it is not easy here, in Czech Republic. (btw., are there in that "Stalin's folly" some numbers? I mean division...
I will try to find something about those "units conscripted by Zhukov" and about those ones conscripted before him. It should to be interesting, I...
To Kai-Petri: I do not understand well? To Sloniksp: I know, that Zhukov was only a man (however his quality is still a question for me, too many...
What exactly do you mean? If is it only my reply just above, there I took your own words about Stalins and Zhukovs authority and Zhukovs claims of...
Thanks for such a huge response. Now I have lots to think about again. But why you quote some of my text and answer to something different? Your...
Here is something I found recently about Glantz and his books, it seems to me, he is only a little more reliable than Suvorov is:...
Well, you did not read anything I wrote here? I.e. your favourite historician David Glantz and whatever he wrote about Rzhev-Sycevka? It seems to...
Yes, I know, that most of Suvorov-Rezjun theories and books are thrash. Worst is the Spetznaz, but this was the only thing (Zhukovs accuzations...
That accuzation is from Suvorov, I am sorry if it is not true but now I cannot to neither to confirm it nor refutate it. (Anything I was able to...
Well, it is surprising for me, that as a chief of the Red Army General Staff (January - July 1941) he had no authority to anything?!? Stalin...
Well, 150,000 was the maximum number of Germans (my estimation) directly attacking Leningrad. Wikis figure of 725,000 is not specified in time,...
I am just startitg to sniff informations about Leningrad (thus I allready got somethig), so for Vlasov again shortly: There were lots of Russians...
Thanks for many informations. Tomorrow I will try to search more about it all, now I have time only to write something short about Vlasov. Maybe...
Ok, if you think, but that (to compare or replace him with someone other) was not my idea in this thread. I just want to show, that not all of...
Well, of course I have some favourite leaders, but it seems to me little off-topic this time and in this thread. But if you really want to see...
Well, by this way ok:) But I tried to bring some serious information here. You know, I believed for long time, that Zhukov was the best...
